Hi guys,
weird, you may be thinking… Happy about a phone and got rid of it a week after. Wonder no longer… I’ll explain to you why I love the phone and still had to bring it back. For this, let’s focus on the main features of the phone – but before I start, I have to say one thing. The look&feel of the device Samsung Galaxy S I9000 is really gorgeous, especially the screen – but there are still reasons not to own one:
Internet connectivity (mail, websites, social networking, Last.FM, Picasa, etc…)
Internet connectivity is definitely a good invest – but, as we all know, the usability of the net mainly depends on the speed you’re connected with. And guess what, the speed of a connection which jumps between GPRS/EDGE and HSDPA is awful. Using the mobile when wireless is available is real fun, though – but who needs a mobile when there’s wireless?
Outdoors cool stuff like Last.fm, picasa, facebook and all the stuff which, basically involve bigger binary data (pictures, sounds, etc.) to be transmitted, is awfully slow and drives me crazy. Last.fm radio f.e. is impossible to use on the road! Same applies for sharing pictures, etc…
Result: At least in germany, whichever service needs a good connection (so basically everything except mail and the calendar), will not work in a satisfying manner.
GPS (Navigation, Tracking, …)
On android phones you can choose whether to use the network connection or the GPS receiver or both to determine your position. The network only will determine your position very fast but also very inaccurate (100meters to kilometers off spot). GPS on the other hand reached about 5 meters accuracy on my phone but took ages to lock on position. Or you can choose to use both methods in combination.
- Network only is not usable as it is so inaccurate, you can’t use it for navigation or tracking – even “my location” puts my to the next village – completely useless.
- GPS only takes ages to start, so e.g. you wanna take a picture with GPS coordinates attached… Who’s going to wait for a few minutes before you can take a picture? No one.
- In combination the phone’s location is locked in seconds – but this will exhaust the battery in no time. I did a journey about an hour in this mode and – woohoo – the battery was beyond 50% afterwards. In about an hour!! My HTC artemis can take several hours of “GPS punishment” without a problem, and this thing is years old!
- Sometimes the GPS receiver is not started properly, which meant I had to quit the application, stop and start the GPS receiver manually, and then start the app again. Annoying. Really.
- Navigation is only as good as the available software is… and it isn’t to good. Even the commercial soft like Navigon is just not working as it should. First of all there are nearly no settings available, e.g. you can’t see the time to target or distance or anything… No comparison to my goold ol’ TomTom 6. And a very nice thing: if someone phoned while navigation was active, the phone worked great – but the navigation did just stop working until the phone call was over – meant after a 5 minute call I had to do a u-turn.
- The GPS tracking software is really cool – but with the annoying gps receiver and the lack of battery it is pretty useless, because most of the time I do wander around a bit longer than 1-2hours…
MP3, Pictures, Videos
The sound and the mp3 player is really good, better than expected. And there’s plenty of battery for the mp3 player available. If the battery is at 100%, 4 to 5hours of listening is possible. But wait – only if everything else, including the screen is disabled. If WLAN or network connectivity, maybe the GPS and the screen is on for some time, the battery will be exhausted after 2 hours. And it is worse when watching video.
And one more word about pictures – I copied about 5000 pictures to the phone, in about 300 albums… And the gallery app can’t actually sort it or show it in a way, which allows easy and fast access to the pictures. Instead, I had to swap about 60 (!) pages to get to the latest pictures. And, additionally, you can’t have subfolders. This is the 20th century, we LOVE subfolders and structures. So why isn’t this possible?
Summary:
If you look out for a phone with great technical possibilities, which are all more or less useless due to a power-leeching hardware, a weak battery, slow internet connectivity in germany, missing usability in the very basic apps, an android mobile will be the right thing for you, especially the the Samsung Galaxy S I9000.
If you can’t stand any of that – do the same thing I’ll do. Buy a cheap 10$ mobile which handles the very basic tasks really great (calls, sms) – or, way better, stick with your current one.
Regards,
Daniel